Improving the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act

Improving the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act: A Path for the Conference Committee

Heritage Foundation
Adam Michel
December 6, 2017

SUMMARY

The House and Senate each past different versions of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. The two versions now head to a conference committee where select lawmakers from both chambers will work towards one unified bill. The conference committee should begin with the Senate-passed bill because the political balance struck in the Senate will be important to maintain for final passage. The House bill, however, has many worthy provisions that will make the Senate bill even stronger.

The Best Parts of the House and Senate Plans

1. 20 Percent Corporate Tax Rate and Expensing. In both bills the corporate tax rate is cut from 35 percent—one of the highest rates in the world—to 20 percent. A 20 percent federal corporate tax rate is the upper bound for global tax competitiveness. Even after adoption of this recommendation, when average state taxes are added in, the U.S. would still have an average cumulative tax rate higher than the worldwide average of 23 percent.

2. Elimination of Tax Subsidies. Both the House and the Senate bills eliminate the state and local tax deduction for income and sales tax and cap the property tax write-off at $10,000. This true structural reform will increase the efficiency and fairness of the entire U.S. tax system. Removing the state and local tax deduction ends the current economically destructive subsidy whereby similar taxpayers in low-tax states pay higher federal taxes than those in high-tax states.

3. Individual Mandate Repeal. The conference committee should include the Senate’s repeal of Obamacare’s individual mandate. Zeroing out the tax, which forces individuals to buy health insurance, would provide tax relief to millions of Americans who cannot afford the rising costs of Obamacare insurance. Repealing the mandate would put anywhere between $695 and $13,100 back into the pockets of American families, if they choose to not purchase the type of health insurance that Obamacare requires.

4. Education Savings Accounts Expansion and Tax Credits Simplification. The House bill includes two important simplifications to education policy that are largely left out of the Senate reform.

Room for Improvement

1. Individual Tax Rates. Neither the House nor the Senate lower personal taxes as far as they should. The House plan consolidates the number of tax brackets from the current seven down to four, but does not lower the current top tax bracket of 39.6 percent. The plan actually raises marginal rates on some taxpayers making over $200,000 and includes a new “bubble tax rate” of 45.6 percent for some high-income earners.

2. Business Deductions. In response to concerns that small and pass-through businesses did not receive a big enough tax cut in the original Senate bill—a dubious claim—the Senate expanded the business deduction from 17.4 percent to 23 percent.

Outstanding Problems in Need of Solutions

1. Repeal the Alternative Minimum Tax. The House bill rightly eliminates the alternative minimum tax (AMT) in both the corporate and individual tax codes. The Senate bill retains both AMTs and raises the threshold where the tax kicks in for individuals.

2. Repeal the Estate Tax. The Senate, like the House, doubles the basic exclusion for the estate tax from its current $5.49 million per person. The Senate, however, never fully repeals the death tax.

3. Make Good Tax Policy Permanent. Due to Senate budget rules, the Senate reforms have many temporary provisions for both individuals and businesses. Tax policy should not be temporary, but instead should strive to provide certainty for taxpayers, now and in the future. Political realities of the Senate budget process mean that many provisions will remain temporary.

Read his analysis and charts HERE.

–00–

The Democrats would have us believe that this new Tax Plan is a serious threat and would bankrupt the country. Perhaps they should remember that the tax code is more easily amended than nearly any act. Maybe they just don’t think Republicans can provide such a “wonderful” product as their own party members produced. Perhaps their objections are because two prominent DEMs wrote the code — Representative Richard Gephardt of Missouri and Senator Bill Bradley of New Jersey. Even the revisions of note were submitted by Democrats: the Revenue Reconciliation Act of 1990 under President George H.W. Bush and the Revenue Reconciliation Acts of 1993 under President Bill Clinton. There was a revision during GW Bush in 2001 that was Republican but it was repealing several penalties inflicted by the prior revisions.

Not one single completely new Tax Plan has been submitted by Democrats since 2009 including during this congressional session. They could have but chose to pick at the older Tax Code and add relief or “fix” only specific items of interest. The Republicans on the other hand have seemed to submit almost yearly at least one bill for a tax overhaul since 2009. So why are the Democrats objecting now — could it be they simply are realizing they might lose control if someone besides themselves actually comes up with a workable plan?

I do not believe that one party or the other has a “corner on the market” in writing tax codes, in fact I shudder when I consider that we are being basically “double and triple taxed”given that the colonies broke away from England over this very issue.

Maybe the tax plan won’t be a great one but then neither was the previous tax code.  U.S. Code: Title 26 -Internal Revenue Code has been on the books since 1986.  It has been added to, rarely revised, and constantly discussed since the day it was signed by the President. This plan will be no different but hopefully will start from a clean slate instead of saying “replace  the word xxx with yyy”.

Heritage Foundation has increasingly received recognition for their work and the current administration seems to rely on their opinions. This is why I am posting their information.

Without getting technical, I can at least see what they are agreeing with, worried about, and concentrating on. It gives me a lot more confidence to know that more than a few professional financial/tax advisors are carefully following what is being crafted into this bill. I just hope that the final product is worth all the angst and rants. 

I personally want to see that the 501(c)3 is slashed out of existence but have yet to see anything that suggests that will happen.

Still hope this helps a little for those like me who aren’t up on things and can only hope the final product is reasonable.

–Uriel– 

 

Orrin Hatch Tells Dems He Is Fed Up with Their “Stinking Class Warfare”

Now I normally do not turn to MSNBC (barf) for video clips, but this one is just too good not to share.  Last night at a Senate Finance Committee meeting discussing the proposed GOP tax plan, Senator Orrin Hatch (R, Utah) unloaded on Senator Sherrod Brown (D, Ohio).  He may be a little late getting into the game, but Senator Hatch said a few things to his “friend” on the other side of the aisle that have needed saying for, oh, decades. Listen to Brown’s comments closely, too, as they are as clear a presentation of Democrat economic propaganda as … Continue reading

What’s Happening in DC? Ask a lobbyist.

What’s Happening in DC? Ask a lobbyist. They seem to know as much as any covert operative what is going on in DC. They ought to since it’s their industry dollars that are greasing the wheels of the system. From the Hill: Advocates are on the front-lines of the capital’s policy battles, laboring to shape the decisions made by Congss and the administration. The members of The Hill’s Top Lobbyists list are all names to know — people who are in the thick of the action from K Street to Capitol Hill. While some of those recognized here are registered … Continue reading

FBI and Congress – Mollifying the Masses or Finally Getting Serious

FBI and Congress – Mollifying the Masses or Finally Getting Serious First Giving Congress Clinton Emails and Second Calling for Mueller to step down    FBI turns over new Clinton investigation documents to Congress The Hill John Solomon November 4, 2017 The FBI has begun turning over to Senate investigators hundreds of pages of memos regarding the bureau’s probe into Hillary Clinton’s private email server, sources told The Hill. The sources said the Justice Department notified the Senate Judiciary Committee late Friday and the FBI began transmitting memos soon after to assist Congress in its review of former Director James … Continue reading

GOP: Here’s Your Silver Platter. Now Wake Up … Or Else.

Next week I expect we will learn if the Republican Party as an entity is worth saving.  Next week, Donna Brazile releases her book on how Queen Douche Hillary Clinton working with the Wasserman-Schulz-controlled DNC stole an election cycle, in a scandal that eclipses anything in American politics since the 19th century. We add this forthcoming MOAB drop to recent revelations about the Obama-Regine-approved Uranium One deal, and how scions of the Democrat Party sold strategic American assets that belong to we the people, to a strategic enemy, for personal financial gain, and then hid the facts under a puddle … Continue reading

In-Depth, Lengthy Congressional Hearings – A reasonable taxpayer expense or a waste of taxpayer dollars

  My point of view. Consider how much Congress has cost the American Taxpayer just in congressional hearings. Consider that Congress has wasted a lot of their DC time over the years on hearings instead of getting laws enacted or managing to maintain a constitutionally sound government. A look back shows a pretty startling fact about the congressional hearings on several key issues: House Select Committee on Assassinations, created in Sept. 1976 to investigate the assassinations of John F. Kennedy and Martin Luther King Jr., lasted 30 months. Committee on Improper Activities in Labor-Management Relations, which looked into labor racketeering, was impaneled … Continue reading

Senate Approves March 2017 Budget Deal, Still has tax cuts, Obamacare, and 2017 Budget to deal with

Senate Approves Budget Deal     Senate passes GOP budget, clears way for work on tax reform Lawmakers pass a $4 trillion budget bill. Fox News Samuel Chamberlain October 20, 2017 Senate Republicans narrowly passed a $4 trillion budget plan Thursday, taking their first big step toward a tax reform package promised by President Donald Trump. Approval of the nonbinding plan allows the Senate to use a special process known as “budget reconciliation” that would forestall a Democratic filibuster. “Tonight we completed the first step towards replacing our broken tax code by passing a comprehensive, fiscally responsible budget that will … Continue reading

President Trump’s Letter to House and Senate Leaders

President Donald J. Trump’s Letter to House and Senate Leaders & Immigration Principles and Policies October 08, 2017 For Release I am pleased to transmit to you my Administration’s principles for reforming our Nation’s immigration system. In 2012, after the Congress rejected legislation offering legal status and work permits to illegal immigrants, the previous Administration bypassed the Congress and granted those same benefits unilaterally. These actions threatened Congress’s status as a coequal branch of Government and have resulted in a surge of illegal immigration. As President, I took an oath to uphold the Constitution, which makes clear that all legislative … Continue reading

Who Is Really To Blame in the Clinton-Comey Controversy?

Who Is To Blame? The Usual Suspect Is the Captain of the Ship, the Chief Executive Officer, the Head of the Department and the Commander-in-Chief… The Clinton-Comey Controversy Continues — Who is to Blame? The Conservative Zone September 13, 2017 Senators Lindsey Graham (R-SC) and Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-IA) are members of the committee tasked with investigating President Donald J. Trump’s firing of former FBI Director James Comey. On August 30, 2016, they sent a letter to the current FBI Director Christopher Wray, requesting any additional documentation related to the former FBI Director’s intent to exonerate Secretary … Continue reading

Trump’s New Ad: “Let The President Do His Job”

The Trump administration has finally tired of allowing the media to craft the narrative for how things are going in Washington, D.C. and they’ve decided to take their message directly to the people. It’s an inventive tactic and whether or not it will work is still up for debate, but the President knows he’s not going to find any sympathetic ears with the mainstream media so the time has come to try something different. Constitution ~Terry

South Koreans Have “Normalized” The NORK Threat. No Panic There. Got That, MSM?

Thursday 10 August, Rush Limbaugh took a brief call from a South Korean national living legally in the USA.  She has many relatives back home in Seoul.  Her message to Rush’s audience?  Chill about Kim Jong-Il.  South Koreans have “normalized” the irrational and dangerous behavior of the dog-eating Dumpling Boy to the north.  They understand that Li’l Kim is living very high off the hog, stashing away billions of dollars scammed from idiot western leaders.  He is, the South Koreans believe, not likely to jeopardize his cushy situation by provoking a military strike launched from the US. I doubted the … Continue reading

Congress – Holding Them Accountable For Performance

Congress – Holding Them Accountable For Performance When we go to work in the public or private sectors, our performance is considered and yearly reviews reflect our work performance. Citizens should be doing the same for their congressional representatives considering we are their employers and paying their salaries. For most of the congress, their salaries are $174,000 per year not counting their status and perks. It is difficult to believe that career politicians can be multimillionaires from that salary amount. So shouldn’t we be asking ourselves how so-called “dedicated” career officials who do not have full-time employment in any sector … Continue reading

Cyber Warfare – The Strange Case Of Congressional and Economic Blindness

  Cyber Warfare – The Strange Case Of Congressional and Economic Blindness History – One example of a shining US star that crashed, burned, or was absorbed by other companies who are no longer located in the US. In 1957 Digital Equipment was founded. It was founded initially to make electronic modules for test, measurement, prototyping and control markets. Eventually it became was a major American company in the computer industry from the 1950s to the 1990s. DEC was a leading vendor of computer systems, including computers, software, and peripherals. Their PDP and successor VAX products were the most successful of … Continue reading

Flashback – Times When Congress Refused to Call Obstruction On Obama

Democrats are determined to roast Trump on obstruction. I like many are sick and tired of the yapping hysterics of liberal media drama queens as well as Democrat and RINO members of Congress. Where were they during Obama’s real obstructions. Remember When? January 28, 2010 – State of Union Address – Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, during the address, Obama took SCOTUS to task for their decision NYT – Supreme Court Gets a Rare Rebuke, in Front of a Nation” Washington Post – Alito v. Obama Reactions split on Obama’s remark, Alito’s response at State of the Union” CNN … Continue reading

Cyber News From DC

  Last week many of the major countries of the world were cyber attacked and hijacked with malware. Even today we may be seeing repercussions here and abroad. What it has done is ratched up the concerns of the world over malevolent attacks. Cyber security has been a growing concern for many years. Certainly on the Hill it has been talked nearly to death without a lot of positive results. As usual Congress simply jabbers and rarely has pushed to achieve on an issue of growing and great concern. Just as the email scandals of the DNC and Hillary Clinton have … Continue reading

Massive Amnesty Proposed: GOP Continues To Treat Symptoms And Ignore The Disease

Some days I read news stories and have to pinch myself to make sure I’m still living in reality.  Well, here’s today’s message from the “different day, same shit” department: Wisconsin Senator Ron Johnson (R) and Colorado Representative Ken Buck (R) have proposed The American Replacement Bill, to import 495,000 foreign workers plus unlimited family members, “to replace Americans who cannot work because of opioid addiction”, and who also dropped out of the workforce during the last two recessions. Johnson and Buck blame this “plague” of “social pathologies” on government policies.  Their solution:  Import more foreign workers.  The legislation is … Continue reading

How George Soros And Leftist Deep-Staters Hijacked USAID

George Whoros … walking dead (oh, how I wish that were true).  Now we get facts that support our suspicions that the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) has been hijacked by progressives on the Soros payroll.  USAID has been turned into the Agency for Anti-American Propaganda … and you and I are paying the bill with our tax dollars.  The Heritage Foundation’s Mike Gonzales published the details on 10 April 2017.  Note how deep-state career bureaucrats are doing their best to protect the Agency’s activities: http://dailysignal.com/2017/04/10/how-rogue-bureaucrats-undermine-sovereignty-and-hurt-american-interests/?utm_source=TDS_Email&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=MorningBell&mkt_tok=eyJpIjoiT1Rjd1pESm1aR0ppTUdNMSIsInQiOiI1OVpkMUpYV3lJdFg0WU1pNEYrTEhGbFl1M2FxR2dBTGVkdTNkXC9QbVBDWWJ5N3REUVViZEtNZ3pKQ2kyT2syZEJzTFpxSFFNRFBJQVV4SWJUc0NIemlQdmV1Z0RpcXZ5V3dMNkszcTQ2MGtEZk90YXJ2TWhacmk4NFFMa1JYbTIifQ%3D%3D The Troubling Relationship Between Soros and US’ Biggest Foreign Aid Agency Foreign … Continue reading

Trump’s Position On Syria Attack – Debate On Authority

Does Trump need congressional approval to strike Syria? The debate, explained. It’s often easier, Congress has found, to just let the president do what he wants.   In Vox’s article updated by Dara Lind on Apr 7, 2017, there was quite a bit of information that we are able to think about on this issue. Without doubt we are already hearing some make the argument that his action was questionable. Surprisingly not from the Democrats or RINOs but from the hardline conservatives. While there is a question, the question should more rightly be – Should any President have the right to … Continue reading

This Is Not “Winning”

According to several online sources, President Trump is about to sign legislation, already approved by the Republican-controlled House and Senate, that will end one of the very few good legacies of King Putt:  Privacy regulations that were designed to protect your data, your identity and your habits and preferences when you shop online, browse the web, or make cell calls.  The ostensible reason is that the current rules are “confusing” and treat cell carriers differently than they do web hosts. So, in typical federal government style, we will see MORE data-collection accruing to big businesses, just to make their targeted … Continue reading

Scenes From The Nunes / Comey Hearings

Courtesy of The Conservative Treehouse blog “The Last Refuge”, here’s the best reveal of James Comey’s allegiance to King Putt, and his too-clever efforts to obfuscate that fact, seen to date. https://theconservativetreehouse.com/2017/03/27/the-case-against-fbi-director-comey-grows-intel-committee-chair-devin-nunes-explains-need-for-white-house-scif-visit/ The Case Against FBI Director Comey Grows – Intel Committee Chair Devin Nunes Explains Need for White House SCIF Visit… Posted on March 27, 2017 by sundance Throughout the day today liberal media have been trying to make a controversy over House Intel Committee Chairman Devin Nunes visiting the White House on the day prior to his press conference revealing surveillance of Trump transition team members. The implication of … Continue reading