Court vs State Dept and DoJ on Suppression of Evidence in Clinton Email FOIA

Court Will Review Clinton Emails over Objections of Tillerson State Department and Sessions Justice Department


Judicial Watch
September 28, 2017

Judicial Watch announced today that a federal judge will personally review, in camera, redacted material from emails discussing Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s use of iPads and iPhones during her tenure at the State Department. Judge Kollar-Kotelly also ordered the State Department to file an affidavit addressing why it should not have to search new Clinton emails recovered. In taking these steps, the court rejected arguments by the Tillerson State Department and its lawyers at the Sessions Justice Department.

The court will review the blacked-out information so as to better ascertain whether the government misconduct exception would require the release of the full emails.  Generally speaking, the government misconduct exception prevents government agencies from withholding information that would shed light on government wrongdoing under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA).

The September 21 court order comes in connection with an April 28, 2015, FOIA lawsuit filed after the State Department failed to respond to a March 10, 2015, request (Judicial Watch, Inc. v. U.S. Department of State (No. 1:15-cv-00646)). Judicial Watch is seeking:

  • All records of requests by former Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton or her staff to the State Department Office Security Technology seeking approval for the use of an iPad or iPhone for official government business; and
  • All communications within or between the Office of the Secretary of State, the Executive Secretariat, and the Office of the Secretary and the Office of Security Technology concerning, regarding, or related to the use of unauthorized electronic devices for official government business.

In March 2016, Judicial Watch obtained State Department documents in this case showing Cheryl Mills’ (Clinton’s then-chief of staff) efforts with the National Security Agency to address Clinton’s demands for a secure BlackBerry.

In a related case, Judicial Watch released an email showing that National Security Agency personnel had denied Clinton’s requests for a BlackBerry, telling Clinton staff to “shut up and color.”

In June 2017, Judicial Watch submitted new evidence to the court showing that Clinton knowingly used an unsecure BlackBerry device despite being warned by “security hawks” against doing so.

“Hillary Clinton knowingly used an unsecure email system and risky iPads and smartphones to conduct classified and sensitive government business,” said Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton. “It is frankly outrageous that Secretary Tillerson and Attorney General Sessions allow their agencies to cover up for and defend Hillary Clinton’s scandalous and potentially criminal conduct.”



Okay… What gives with this new administration State Dept. and DoJ?  I would say that President Trump’s group is being undermined by prior administration holdovers, except both Tillerson and Sessions have been purging and rearranging their departments since they took office. Those that put this administration in office expect to have their wishes carried out — bring Clinton before the court and in a fair and (if at all possible) non-partisan way rip into her and expose her activities so that this whole mess can end.

It appears, at least on the surface, that only one group JUDICIAL WATCH is hammering for this to be exposed. The election of Trump did not appease the justifiable anger of the citizens that one wealthy witch managed to buy her way out of a trial when there are a lot locked away for far less.


Let her have her day in court and not one pre-stacked with liberals who will allow her to skate.


About Uriel

Retired educator and constitutionalist
Tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Court vs State Dept and DoJ on Suppression of Evidence in Clinton Email FOIA

  1. Hardnox says:

    Thank goodness for JW otherwise this would be a long dead topic but I’m not holding my breath that justice will be served.

    The purging of the DoJ and State needs to continue. A purge of congress is also in order which is why Hildabeast hasn’t been held accountable.

  2. GunnyG says:

    DC needs to be nuked. Period.

  3. whitetop says:

    It seems there is enough evidence in the public record to put Hillary into the bar window hotel for a long time but there seems to be tunnel vision on the part of people who could make that happen; Sessions being the prime candidate. I think there has been enough ink printed about Sessions lack of attention to the job he was hired to do.

  4. Uriel says:

    One would think there is but obviously the solid evidence still remains at the FBI, State Dept. and DoJ. IF DOJ did their job on this is would already have been in the courts.