Fundamentalist Islam Flawed – Humanitarian Nightmare

This past week has been an emotional time for me. A beloved friend and companion for sixteen years passed away.  He came to me lost and nearly drowned at eight weeks old and for all those years even up to nearly the last day, followed, protected, and loved me unconditionally.

Pet owners across the world understand that feeling where their animal waits patiently until we return home and greet us with love and kindness especially when our day has been really bad. They are there in good and bad times to lift our spirits, to protect us from harm if need be with their very lives. They show us what it means to love, respect, and honor our dearest friends even when we ignore them for a stretch of time.

They exasperate, create messes, and at times we wish them to be gone just as any other member of the family. They have personalities and quirks no different from humans yet for all their little faux paws, are our closest friends who listen patiently when we rant and comfort us when we cry.

I could count on his assessment of strangers to be accurate and knew that those he took a decided dislike to were people I also wanted to hold at arm’s length and often through experience found he was most often right in the character and trustworthiness of those he vetted.

In those last minutes of his life, my friend Max only wanted to be close and comforted by the one he trusted above all others — me. It was my honor and privilege to hold him close in those last seconds as he showed dignity and love in the natural order of life – the passing from this place to the beyond.


When I read the following piece I was particularly distraught that anyone in the world could be so horrific to humans and animals.

Every day we see or hear about abused and forsaken animals left to fend for themselves or die. In fact there are many dogs here in the US who every day are rescued by volunteers and need our help to protect or find them forever homes.

My dad long ago said that there was something soulless or broken within a person if they could not respond to a pet. I have seen nothing over the intervening years that disputes that saying.

Soldiers have four-legged partners that work just as hard as their human counterparts. These are highly trained and skilled dogs who deserve our respect and love just like their human partners. Yet when over in other countries, these four-legged soldiers have been left behind, abused by paramilitary groups or killed by Islamic terrorists for practice and sport. Thankfully over recent years, this is happening less as those same four-legged partners have more and more been reunited with handlers or with soldiers here who need their care as much as they need to be cared for.

Enforcement officers and rescue professionals are also relying on those same skilled animals to preserve and protect here at home. Yet still we hear of many being killed in the line of duty or attacked as they go about their jobs.

The article below is a humanitarian nightmare for women, pet owners, and defenseless animals. It points up to me, and should to people across the world, one of many vast differences between fundamentalist Islamic beliefs and those who have learned what love, kindness, and a different gentler religion mean.


The event is jarring and horrific in its hate not only for pets but for those who love and care for pets. Pay attention and see the real fundamentalism practices of a religion and a state ideology that is attempting to consume and destroy western culture. Then decide for yourselves if this is what we are willing to accept in the United States.

Woman Brutally Beaten for the ‘Sin’ of Walking Her Dog

Clarion Project
By Uzay Bulut
March 8, 2017

A woman who went to a public park to walk her dog in the city of Canakkale, Turkey was attacked by three women with Islamic headscarves.

According to an article in the local newspaper, Canakkale Olay, the woman, identified as A.K., was walking her dog in a municipal park in the Barbaros neighborhood when she was approached by a woman with a hijab in her late 30s who said to her, “This building complex and the park is ours. You cannot walk your dog here, it is a sin.”

The woman allegedly also said to the dog keeper, “Are you a kafir [infidel]? You are playing with a dog. Isn’t that a sin?”

Two other women with headscarves joined in and it quickly turned into a physical attack.  The attackers allegedly smashed A.K.’s head on the stones in the park and hit her in the head with a marble block. Luckily, some passersby were able to restrain the attackers and save A.K.

Later, when A.K. said she would call the police, one of the attackers countered by saying that her husband is a prosecutor and the police would do nothing.

A.K. managed to make it to a local hospital for treatment and received a medical report proving the battering. A number of relatives of the attackers  followed A.K. to the hospital and threatened her saying, “Only your dead body will be able to leave this hospital.”

A.K. then went to a police station and filed a complaint against the attackers.

This is not the first incidence in Canakkale against “man’s best friend.” On February 3, the Turkish newspaper Sabah reported that “an animal massacre” took place in the city.

“Many cats and dogs in several neighborhoods across Canakkale were poisoned to death after eating pieces of meat that had been injected with high doses of pesticides and scattered throughout the streets in the city,” the newspaper stated.

Many similar incidents against dogs and their owners have been recorded across majority-Muslim countries, some of which take legal action against dog owners.

For example, under a law passed in 2014 by the Iranian government, owning a dog in Iran can result in 74 lashes.

In Malaysia, Muslim clerics voiced their outrage after event was held in a park called “I want to touch a dog,” challenging the stigma around the animal. The organizer of the event was forced into hiding after receiving death threats.

Social media is filled with videos of how dogs are murdered, beaten or abused in many areas across Muslim-majority countries.

Given how loyal, dependable and self-sacrificing dogs are, violence against them is completely irrational.

In order to understand this hostile attitude, one needs to examine the Islamic theological foundations that promote a dislike of and brutality toward the animal. According to certain hadiths — words and deeds attributed to Islam’s founder, Mohammed — dogs are considered “impure,” “unclean” and “evil.” Killing them is encouraged in hadith 3811 and hadith 551.

Several Islamic websites also clarify the Islamic stance against dogs. For example, according to the Islamic website Albalagh, “‘Angels do not enter a house wherein there is a dog or an animate picture’ (Sahih Bukhari Hadith 2986). In the light of these Ahaadith and other narrations it is not permissible to keep dogs as pets. The household is deprived of the Mercy of Allah Taãla.”

The website Islam Q&A states, “With regard to keeping dogs, this is haraam [forbidden] and is in fact a major sin,” because, “The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: ‘Whoever keeps a dog, a qiraat from his good deeds will be deducted every day, except a dog for farming or herding livestock’. It is said that the kaafirs [infidels], Jews, Christians and communists in the east and the west all keep dogs, Allaah forbid. Each one takes his dog with him and cleans it every day with soap and other cleansing agents. But even if he were to clean it with the water of all the seas in the world and all the soap in the world, it would never become pure! Because its impurity is inherent, and inherent impurity cannot be cleansed except by destroying it and erasing it altogether.”

Unfortunately, similar hostile attitudes against dogs have also been reported in Western countries.

According to several British media outlets, Muslim drivers have forced blind people and their guide dogs off buses because they consider the animals to be “unclean,” and police sniffer dogs trained to spot terrorists at railway stations may no longer come into contact with Muslim passengers after complaints that it is against their religion.

There have also been other cases when blind or disabled people in the UK accompanied by dogs faced Muslim hostility in hospitals and supermarkets or were turned away from restaurants “because the guide dog offended Muslim staff.”

But just as the persecution of women and religious minorities under sharia rule is ignored by many Western feminists and human rights activists, persecution of animals – particularly of dogs – remains ignored by Western animal rights activists.



About Uriel

Retired educator and constitutionalist
Tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Fundamentalist Islam Flawed – Humanitarian Nightmare

  1. SafeSpace says:

    For those looking to help abandoned dogs AND our military at the same time, here’s a link to a superb organization that rescues and places abandoned dogs, plus works to return combat dogs from the front lines (where they are often left behind on orders of the brass) and reunite them with their handlers stateside. This outfit gets a good rating from Charity Navigator, too:

    • Uriel says:

      Thanks so much for the add SafeSpace. When I was looking for pictures I was sickened by some showing dozens of slaughtered canine soldiers left over there and trained by Fort Polk. It wasn’t ISIS but paramilitary that killed them dammit. These soldiers deserved better than that.

  2. SafeSpace says:

    The Islam / dog story serves as yet another fine illustration of the extraordinary ignorance and assbackwardness of Islam. Seems to me police in the UK should damn well use sniffer dogs — helps ’em spot the hijab-wearing, walking sleeper cells that much quicker. Someone ought to tell Imam Bin Jackwagon that many civilized folk consider Islam to be unclean….

    • Uriel says:

      Agreed. They are worse than animals. Those do not kill for pleasure. The whole fundamentalism Islam BS is not deserving of anything more than slaughter. If it isn’t PC then so be it.

  3. Felinity says:

    Safe Space and I express our heartfelt condolences for your beloved Max…we’ve let six sweet felines go to Kitty Heaven over the past 40-odd years and know the heartbreak only too well. This regardless of knowing that the word “animal” is derived from the Latin word for anima/animus which means “soul” = we’ll see our four leggers again one day, thanks be!

    BTW, our present cat’s name is…Max. He’s a handsome gray-and-white tuxedo who loves us each so very much — he’s one heck of a belly presenter!

    As for the TRUE animals in every sense of the Western usage regarding those embracing the peaceful religion of Islam…what the hey do y’all expect? They worship at the altar of decimation and death…and raise their butts high in the air as they pray, showing SUCH respect for almighty Allah. Of COURSE dogs and cats are easy prey to vent their dark-ages hatred and wrath!

    In case you’re not familiar with it, here’s a link to Cynthia Rylant’s “Dog Heaven”; we have a copy of her “Cat Heaven”. God bless and stay strong, Uriel!

    • Uriel says:

      Thank you Felinity. I also have had others including one beloved cat. It is still heart wrenching.

  4. vonMesser says:

    It’s my personal belief that Moham-mud was bitten by a dog while raping either as goat or the farmer’s 6 year old daughter. Couldn’t stand them after that.

  5. Terry says:

    My condolences for your loss Uriel.
    And my condolences also to all living creatures who have to share this earth with the savage, unclean, barbaric, pieces of filth known as muslims.