Barely Half of Illegal Border Crossers Caught

From AP:

Barely half of people who entered the U.S. illegally from Mexico last year were caught, according to a report commissioned by the Department of Homeland Security that also shows sharp declines in illegal entries.

The report found 54 percent of people who entered illegally between border crossings got caught in the 2015 fiscal year. That’s much lower than the 81 percent success rate that Homeland Security cited publicly using a different counting method.

The 98-page report was completed in May, and Homeland Security has declined to release it. The Associated Press obtained a copy from a government official involved in border issues who acted on condition of anonymity because it has not been made public.

The report offers some of most detailed measures yet of how secure the border with Mexico is – a major issue in a presidential campaign that features Republican nominee Donald Trump calling for a wall along the entire 1,954-mile border. It includes enough material to argue that the government has made significant strides or that it is falling short.

In terms of people, 170,000 eluded capture during the 2015 fiscal year, 210,000 the previous year, and 1.7 million in 2005. The number of people who eluded capture is larger when including those who escaped detection at border crossings or who entered by sea, which is the responsibility of Homeland Security agencies outside the Border Patrol. Adding those, 200,000 people got away last year, 260,000 in 2014, and 1.9 million in 2005.

The huge drop in illegal entries over the last decade coincides with increases in border security spending, which has reached $14 billion annually. The report notes more serious consequences imposed on illegal crossers during that period, which include jail time.

Immigration experts have also cited the significant decline in job opportunities after the Great Recession that began at the end of 2007. Still, sharp declines in illegal entries have continued in recent years as the economy improved.

“This is the first solid evidence we have that the border buildup of the last 20 years has indeed made some significant difference in deterring and reducing illegal entries across the southern border,” said Edward Alden, senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations.

The department said Thursday that the report was “one building block provided by a research organization” toward developing more reliable measures of border security and that its methodology needed refinement.

“DHS does not believe it is in the public interest to release, and it would be irresponsible to make policy or other judgments on the basis of analysis that is incomplete and remains a work in progress,” spokeswoman Marsha Catron said.

The Border Patrol’s capture rate on the Mexican border was 55 percent in 2014 and 36 percent in 2005, according to the report prepared for Homeland Security by the Institute for Defense Analyses, a federally funded research organization. The Border Patrol achieved an 11-point improvement in 2014 after years of slow but steady gains.

The report offers detailed analysis going back to 2000, shortly before the U.S. erected hundreds of miles of border fences, added surveillance gear and doubled the number of Border Patrol agents. Homeland Security has been under pressure to show if those multibillion-dollar investments yielded results.

The primary measure that Homeland Security has publicly released is the number of Border Patrol arrests, which tells how many people got caught but not how many got away. Arrests dropped to the lowest level in 44 years in 2015, down 80 percent from a peak of nearly 1.7 million in 2000.

For the last two years, the department has released an “interdiction effectiveness rate” that measures the percentage of people who got caught among all who attempted to enter between crossings on the Mexican border. The figure – which was 81 percent last year – includes those who set foot in the U.S. and turned around and asylum-seekers.

The report obtained by the AP does not credit the government for people who turn around or turn themselves in to agents to seek asylum, a common occurrence among Central American women and children who have entered the country in large numbers over the last five years.

The report says there were 140,000 asylum seekers on the Mexican border last year and 170,000 in 2014, compared to about 20,000 a year a decade ago. Homeland Security’s practice of counting those as captures goes a long way toward explaining why its success rate was so much higher.

Counting border crossers who elude capture is a mammoth and imprecise task but one that many experts believe is necessary to judge whether the border is secure. Homeland Security approaches the job by tracking physical evidence, such as footprints in the desert and other signs of human presence, and by agent sightings. The internal report uses that information, along with migrant surveys and techniques developed by social scientists.


Where is the surprise?  The administration is using the same bullshit math to publish the official numbers as they do with unemployment figures.  If the numbers aren’t what they want then they use parameters that favor their desired narrative.  Garbage in equals garbage out.  Even easier when we have a water carrying media who won’t ask a question.

My buddy from back in high school, who recently retired as an official in the Border Patrol, tells me the numbers are much worse than reported.  The virtual fence has been removed/deactivated since 2009.  The Border Patrol had been ordered back from the border.  Even the unpublished numbers are bullshit.  The Border Patrol grunts know it too.

My greatest concern are the OTMs (other than Mexicans) from every Stan country on the planet that are within our borders.  They come via the drug cartels.  My buddy estimates the number at about 200,000.  That’s right, TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND.  The people at the top know these estimates.  These jihadis aren’t here on vacation or looking for work.

How that isn’t treason, then I don’t know what it.

~ Hardnox

About Hardnox

Constitutional Conservative that Lefties love to hate.
Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Barely Half of Illegal Border Crossers Caught

  1. SafeSpace says:

    The law of unintended consequences at work again: Obama’s crap recovery has improved border security. Americans, get used to no jobs and you’ll enjoy a bonus of fewer illegals.

  2. Pingback: HN&F | Barely Half of Illegal Border Crossers Caught |

  3. Just Gene says:

    I know my bringing up math can be a pain BUT how can one know the % if there is no accurate total – pure BS!!!!

  4. Uriel says:

    More of the Brotherhood core math at work here. The magician with his card tricks aren’t nearly as skilled as prestidigitation as these number manipulators. Just this week there are reports that Obama has halted ANY deportations until after November ummmmm yeah and we know why.

  5. Vic Mazza says:

    Dear Americans,

    Just this one irresponsible, unforgiveable tort of not enforcing our border security should be grounds for immediate termination of our elected officials… from the top down.

    Should any check cashing politician, right or left criticize Mr. Trump, this situation dwarfs anything! How dare these selfish, self serving, greedy, useless people be on the payroll of hard working Americans….

    This is why Mr. Trump will win….their out, we are in!

    Vic Mazza