Rubio and Cruz release tax returns, Pressuring Trump to follow

From:,  by Eugene Scott, Chris Frates and Theodore Schleifer,  on Feb 27, 2016,  see the article HERE.

Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks at a rally at Drake University in Des Moines, Iowa, Thursday, Jan. 28, 2016. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik)

Washington (CNN)Florida Sen. Marco Rubio and Texas Sen. Ted Cruz released income and federal tax data Saturday as part of an attempt to pressure Donald Trump, the Republican presidential front-runner, to do the same.

Rubio released five years’ worth of financial information, saying the rates his family paid were in line with tax rates paid by Americans of similar income levels. And Cruz and his wife disclosed four years’ worth, bringing in more income than did the Rubio family.

But both campaigns only released the top lines of the forms, not the complete documents, providing only a limited look at their finances. Democrats and some Republicans quickly pounced on Rubio and Cruz for the limited release.

The moves from Cruz and Rubio come as Trump is under pressure to release his tax returns. 2012 GOP nominee Mitt Romney warned there could be a “bombshell” in Trump’s documents. Trump has so far declined to release his tax information, saying he’s being audited.

“It is time to stop the excuses,” Cruz said in a statement. “If Donald is embarrassed about his tax returns, it’s up to the voters to assess the facts.”

When asked about why only summaries were released, Cruz offered to disclose more information if other candidates did.

“If Marco wants to release the complete thing for the recent years, I’m happy to do so as well and I would certainly encourage Donald Trump to do it, but we just did it to match what the other candidates are doing,” Cruz told reporters.

Rubio promised to release additional tax information in the future, but wanted to get the summaries out for the sake of time.

“We’ll do the rest too,” Rubio told reporters. “We just wanted to get it out there quickly so people could see the summaries.”

Cruz and his wife Heidi, a Goldman Sachs executive in Houston, made about $5 million from 2011 to 2014, the documents show. They paid about $1.5 million in taxes on that money, according to the joint returns.

The effective tax rate on that money ranged in those years from 28.54% to 32.22%, according to the campaign.

The couple’s top grossing year was 2011, when they together earned $1.73 million. That figure fell to $970,000 in 2013, Cruz’s first year in the Senate.

Prior to 2013, the Cruz family made much of their money in 2011 and 2012 through means other than wages and salaries, banking about $2.1 million. Because the returns were incomplete, it was not immediately clear how the income was earned. In 2013 and 2014, their income came from more traditional wages and salaries.

Rubio reported less income at points. Rubio’s campaign said on its website that the family has earned $2.29 million since 2010, paying a total of $526,092 in taxes on that income. The campaign published joint federal tax returns from Rubio and his wife, Jeanette.

“There is no doubt the Rubio family has come a long way from the days when their largest monthly expense was a check to Sallie Mae and checks were sent in the mail to pay bills with the hope the payment did not arrive before the next paycheck was deposited into their account,” he said.

The Rubios’ income includes his earnings from his U.S. Senate salary, Florida International University, Rubio’s legal work, his books and Jeanette’s work at a philanthropic foundation, the campaign said.

Rubio saw a significant spike in income in 2012, earning $929,439 in 2012, the year his book, “An American Son: A Memoir” was released.

Rubio’s tax rate was 27.4% that year. The average tax rate for similar earners was 22.8%, the campaign said, citing the Tax Foundation, a conservative group.

In 2014, Rubio earned $335,561, paying a tax rate of 19.3%.

Democrats quickly attacked Rubio and Cruz for the limited release, saying former GOP presidential nominee Romney and former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush released their full returns. They questioned why the pair isn’t willing to do the same thing he’s calling on Trump to do.

“Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio are guilty of a stunning lack of disclosure, failing to meet the standard that even Mitt Romney and Jeb Bush adhered to in 2012, when he released his tax returns and making it impossible to complete a public accounting of deductions, exemptions, capital gains, household employees, corporate ownerships, and other important financial information,” said Ben Ray, a spokesman for American Bridge 21st Century, which conducts opposition research on Republican candidates. “What are they hiding?”

And Mike Murphy, the director of Right to Rise USA, the Bush-aligned super PAC, said Rubio should release more returns to put more pressure on Trump.

“2 page top lines is a bit too clever by half… They should release ten years. Full tax docs. Raise heat on Trump,” Murphy said.


Trump’s not going to release his tax records, why? Come to your own conclusions. He doesn’t take kindly to anyone suggesting that his wealth is anything less than what he professes it to be.

He’s already sued Timothy O’brien when O’brien claimed in a book that Trump’s net worth was about 1/20th of the figure Donald was quoting. Trump sued (for $5 billion dollars), saying that those low figures cost him business deals and hurt his reputation. The judge dismissed the suit and Trump later lost on appeal. The court concluded that Trump was an untrustworthy source for estimates of his own net worth. If Trump refused to provide his tax returns while losing a $5 billion dollar lawsuit, he’s not likely to produce them now.

If Trump does release his tax returns (don’t bet the farm on it) and his net worth is even close to what he professes, I’ll be happy to volunteer a public apology and call for Cruz and Rubio to do the same.


Tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Rubio and Cruz release tax returns, Pressuring Trump to follow

  1. Uriel says:

    IRS has according to posts said he can release the returns without problems now. I seriously doubt he will though. I am wondering if he thought about this before entering race. A lot of deals in the pipeline might have been or be affected.

  2. tannngl says:

    There won’t be a release by Trump. It would hurt his veracity and his ego. And don’t anyone ever harm that ego. He’ll sue you.

  3. Kathy says:

    Murphy is asking them to reveal too much, which leaves them nothing to counter with if Trump were to release his top two lines. Let’s see Trump release the same and go from there. I doubt he’ll fork them over, but he doesn’t have to – his voters don’t care.

    I could be mistaken, but I don’t think this is mandatory until a candidate becomes the nominee. Cruz and Rubio are trying to expose him before he becomes the nominee, but I doubt this will rattle him much, and it sure won’t change the minds of his idolizing fans.

  4. Uriel says:

    according to e-file returns for presidential hopefuls and presidents didn’t become commonplace until the 1960’s only Gerald Ford refused to release his. What’s the point—there is no hard rule to release them nor law stating apparently. Only public pressure has created the posting of returns. If as I believe Trump sees this as an out then he more than likely will never release them at least not prior to taking office if elected.